| BFFL Pro Bowl - 2009 | |||||||
| American Division (Scott Miller, Willow Grove Jackals) | |||||||
| Pos | Player | NFL | BFFL | Pts | Team | Players | |
| QB | Shaub, Matt | HOU | VA | 9 | Willow Grove | 4 | |
| Romo, Tony | DAL | VA | 8 | Durango | 4 | ||
| RB | Johnson, Chris | TEN | LE | 11 | Kalamazoo | 2 | |
| Peterson, Adrian | MIN | VA | 3 | Leningrad | 3 | ||
| Charles, Jamaal | KC | WG | 15 | Vandalay | 5 | ||
| Gore, Frank | SF | WG | 10 | ||||
| WR | Jackson, DeSean | PHI | VA | 0 | |||
| Holmes, Santonio | PIT | VA | 3 | ||||
| Colston, Marques | NO | DU | 0 | ||||
| Smith, Steve | NYG | DU | 3 | ||||
| TE | Witten, Jason | DAL | LE | 8 | |||
| Celek, Brent | PHI | KA | 5 | ||||
| K | Kaeding, Nate | SD | WG | 8 | |||
| Prater, Matt | DEN | DU | 5 | ||||
| OFF | Denver | DEN | KA | 4 | |||
| Tennessee | TEN | DU | 4 | ||||
| DEF | Chicago | CHI | WG | 4 | |||
| Denver | DEN | LE | -4 | ||||
| Total: | 96 | ||||||
| McNicholas Division (Jeff Butscher, Loch Ness Monsters) | |||||||
| Pos | Player | NFL | BFFL | Pts | Team | Players | |
| QB | Rodgers, Aaron | GB | LN | 6 | Del Val | 3 | |
| Cutler, Jay | CHI | VE | 13 | Edgmont | 2 | ||
| RB | Jones-Drew, Maurice | JAC | DV | 0 | Loch Ness | 4 | |
| Rice, Ray | BAL | LN | 0 | Sun City | 3 | ||
| Williams, Ricky | MIA | VE | 0 | Venice | 6 | ||
| Jones, Thomas | NYJ | DV | 6 | ||||
| WR | Moss, Randy | NE | SC | 0 | |||
| Fitzgerald, Larry | ARI | LN | 3 | ||||
| Austin, Miles | DAL | ED | 0 | ||||
| Welker, Wes | NE | LN | 0 | ||||
| TE | Winslow, Kellen | TB | ED | 2 | |||
| Olsen, Greg | CHI | VE | 8 | ||||
| K | Akers, David | PHI | VE | 0 | |||
| Longwell, Ryan | MIN | DV | 11 | ||||
| OFF | Minnesota | MIN | VE | 6 | |||
| Atlanta | ATL | SC | 6 | ||||
| DEF | NY Jets | NYJ | SC | 16 | |||
| Baltimore | BAL | VE | 5 | ||||
| Total: | 82 | ||||||